AI Compares Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings and Finally Settles Which Franchise Is Actually Better

Contents:
Comparisons between these two sagas have been going on for over 20 years: some believe that J.K. Rowling's magical world is more relatable to audiences, while others swear allegiance to Tolkien's epic. This time, AI has settled the debate for fans by analyzing both franchises across key parameters — from characters to cultural impact.

Who Won This Battle

The main argument for "The Lord of the Rings" comes down to scope. When it comes to world-building depth, constructed languages, history, and mythology, Tolkien stands in a league of his own. The AI awarded points for sheer foundational strength — and it's hard to argue with that logic.
Two groups of people glaring at each other against blue and orange backgrounds
Characters from "The Lord of the Rings" and "Harry Potter" according to AI
Source: chatgpt.com
But "Harry Potter" has a different ace up its sleeve — emotional connection. Rowling's saga gets compared to a "coming-of-age school" that grows alongside its readers and viewers. This accessibility makes Potter timeless, creating a magical world that feels personally meaningful to everyone.

Characters

Gandalf and Dumbledore, Frodo and Harry, Sauron and Voldemort — the AI pointed out that both franchises build on identical archetypes.

But victory went to Tolkien again: his characters feel more layered and tragic. Still, audiences might disagree — after all, it's the charisma of Potter's heroes that keeps the story relevant in today's world.
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring Trailer

Film Adaptations

Here the artificial intelligence proved ruthless. Peter Jackson's "The Lord of the Rings" earned top marks — for visual revolution and 11 Oscars. The Harry Potter films, however, were deemed inconsistent: the early entries had fairy-tale charm, the later ones dramatic scope, but overall quality fluctuated.

Great, But Different

The AI declared "The Lord of the Rings" the stronger franchise — for depth, scale, and cinematic influence. But honestly, comparing it to "Harry Potter" is like debating whether hot chocolate or cocoa tastes better.
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Trailer
Tolkien created an epic for those who love massive battles and deeply crafted history on an epic scale, while Rowling crafted a cozy coming-of-age story filled with magic and school hijinks. Each franchise excels in its own genre, and neither diminishes the greatness of the other.

What Else to Watch

And if these two franchises aren't enough for you, here are five more you can rewatch endlessly:
  • "The Chronicles of Narnia" — good versus evil through the eyes of children and talking lions.
  • "Game of Thrones" (okay, at least the first seasons) — an epic where political intrigue rivals magic.
  • "Percy Jackson and the Olympians" — for those who want Hogwarts but with Greek gods.
  • "The Witcher" — monsters, irony, and destiny that always finds you.
  • "His Dark Materials" — a philosophical fairy tale about freedom and growing up.
Earlier, we at zoomboola.com told you how an AI created a screenplay for "Forrest Gump 2," where Forrest travels across 2010s America.