From `Terminator` to `Toy Story`: movies with a 100% critics rating that spark debates among viewers

100% on Rotten Tomatoes means the movie is perfect, right? Critics rave, audiences must be in complete awe… but it's not that simple. Even recognized masterpieces sometimes spark debate. Let's figure out why some films with perfect critic scores leave audiences in doubt.

The Terminator (1984) — Timeless Action or Naive Science Fiction?

James Cameron gave the world one of the most iconic sci-fi action films, but even cult projects lose their magic over time. Not all viewers today perceive The Terminator with the same enthusiasm as before.

The special effects, which looked revolutionary in the '80s, now provoke indulgent smiles — especially the scenes with Schwarzenegger's animatronic head. Moreover, the simplicity of the plot is disappointing: a cold-blooded machine chases a woman, and a brave protector tries to save her. Yet, it is this minimalist, almost noir atmosphere that makes the film so unique and memorable.

Arnold Schwarzenegger as the Terminator in black sunglasses and a leather coat, holding a gun in his right hand — Scene from the movie "The Terminator"

Twelve Angry Men (1957) — A Brilliant Noir or Theater of the Absurd?

How can a film captivate an audience when it's just people sitting in a room arguing? But "Twelve Angry Men" is not just a conversation; it's a tense psychological battle that's impossible to look away from.

Critics call the film a benchmark of drama, and The Guardian included it in the list of the most powerful crime films of all time. However, modern viewers consider the film too slow and overloaded with dialogue. In the era of blockbusters and quick scene cuts, such a leisurely pace is not for everyone.

Twelve men in a room, some sitting at the table, some standing, they are arguing — A scene from 'Twelve Angry Men'

A Room with a View (1985) — Elegant Drama or Boredom?

Some believe that "A Room with a View" is overly long and steeped in British propriety. For fans of dynamic dramas, this film may simply seem boring.

Yet critics continue to admire this picture. The stunning landscapes, elegant script, and heartfelt performance by Helena Bonham Carter make the film a true visual delight. On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds a perfect 100%, and for those who appreciate beautiful stories of forbidden emotions and social conventions, this film will be a true find.

Young Helena Bonham Carter in the film 'A Room with a View' — Still from the film 'A Room with a View'

The Seven Samurai (1954) — A Standard or a Three-Hour Ordeal?

"The Seven Samurai contains dozens, possibly hundreds, of cinematic techniques that revolutionized the way films tell their stories," writes film critic Brendan Hodges. Akira Kurosawa's classic truly inspired many adventure films — from The Magnificent Seven to Guardians of the Galaxy.

The plot of the film is simple yet captivating: peasants suffering from bandit attacks hire seven samurai to protect their village. But here's the problem: the film runs for over three hours. Yes, it's an epic story, but for the viewer, it can be a tough experience. However, if long black-and-white films without special effects are your favorite entertainment, then this is definitely for you.

Seven samurai in a glade against the sky — Scene from the film "The Seven Samurai"

Singin' in the Rain (1952) — Timeless Classic or Overrated Hit?

What could be better than a film about Hollywood? Only a film about Hollywood with songs, dances, and great humor! "Singin' in the Rain" is considered the quintessential musical of the golden age: it's a fun, stylish, and timeless picture. It tells the story of the transition from silent films to talkies with such self-irony that it still feels fresh even after 70 years.

But there are those who find the film overrated. "Everything is so silly — overacting at every turn, Cosmo's ridiculous clowning, and some of the most tasteless techniques imaginable in the dance numbers," comments a regular on IMDd. But if you enjoy vibrant musicals with a touch of retro, "Singin' in the Rain" is guaranteed to bring you joy.

Rain, evening street, a man is holding onto a lamp post with one hand and singing, in the other hand he has a closed umbrella — Scene from the film "Singin' in the Rain"

Toy Story 2 (1999) — Can a Sequel Be Better Than the Original?

Many viewers found the sequel to "Toy Story" less witty and heartfelt. They note that the second part has too much action, chases, and secondary storylines, which detract from the original's intimate charm.

However, critics think otherwise. Todd McCarthy of Variety compares "Toy Story 2" to the hit "The Empire Strikes Back," which also turned out to be "more rich and enjoyable in every way."

Indeed, Pixar achieved the incredible — creating a sequel that not only matches the first part but even surpasses it in some aspects. The captivating adventure, complex moral dilemmas of the characters, and emotional depth made "Toy Story 2" one of the best animated sequels in the history of cinema.

A scene from the cartoon: a toy cowboy and astronaut playing video games on the floor of a children's room — A scene from the cartoon "Toy Story 2"

Achieving 100% positive reviews is a rare accomplishment. But that doesn't mean the film will appeal to everyone. Critics look at art, style, and depth, while viewers focus on emotions, dynamics, and personal impressions. If a movie with a flawless rating didn't captivate you, don't worry — there are plenty of films in the world that will be perfect for you.

Do you agree with the critics' assessments, or do you think they are mistaken? Let's discuss in the comments!